Question 1: Hash & MAC Security
In a certain network protocol, each datagram consists of a 256-bit header and a 256-bit payload. An organization decides to store hashed datagrams for analytic purposes. These hash values need to be calculated on resource-limited devices that can only process data in 256-bit chunks. Thankfully, the devices have hardware implementations of the following cryptographic algorithms:
Since the internal hash function H cannot process entire datagrams, it is necessary to design a hashing method that can compute datagram hashes based on the internally implemented algorithms. The engineers come up with the following designs for hashing datagrams:
Design A: Hash separately, then XOR, i.e.,
Hash(datagram) := H(header) _ H(payload) .
Design B: Hash separately, then hash the concatenated results, i.e.,
Hash(datagram) := H( H(header) k H(payload) ) .
Design C: Apply SHACAL to the payload (as input block) using the header as key, then XOR the result with the header, i.e.,
Hash(datagram) := SHACALheader(payload) _ header .
In these designs, _ denotes the bit-wise exclusive-or operation and k denotes string concatenation. The designed datagram-hashing method is called Hash to distinguish it from the internal hash function H.
(i) .The organization needs to develop a program that looks at the stored datagram hash values and for any two hashed datagrams reliably distinguishes if the original datagrams were identical or not. Identify the security requirement on datagram hashing in this case, and briefly justify your answer.
(ii)Consider the three candidate designs A, B, and C above. For each design, discuss whether or not it satisfies the security requirement identified in part (i). In each case, provide a convincing argument or an attack to support your answer.
Now assume that besides calculating datagram hash values, the devices are to transmit the datagrams to a central monitoring platform over a public network. The devices apply a message-authentication code MAC to hashed datagrams and send the following information to the monitoring platform.
datagram, MACK( Hash(datagram) )
Assume that MAC is secure and the MAC key K is securely pre-shared between a device and the monitoring platform. Since datagrams are not required to remain confidential, no encryption is used, and the above information is sent in the clear over the network. Hence, the network communication might be observed, blocked, or modified by third parties. The monitoring platform performs MAC verification upon receiving any communication and only accepts the incoming communication if MAC verification succeeds.
(iii). The authenticity and integrity of the received communication are important to the monitoring platform. In other words, the platform needs to make sure any communication it accepts is indeed from the device and that the information has not been tampered with in transit. Identify the security requirement on the MAC component for the above protocol to provide authenticity and integrity guarantees. Briefly justify your answer.
(iv). Consider Designs B and C only. For each design when used in the protocol above, discuss if the required goals of authenticity and integrity are met. In each case, provide a convincing argument or an attack to support your answer.