this is a critique paper assignment. it has assigned readings and needs to be based of those readings. you can either agree or disagree with the reading and you only choose of of them to choose your opinion on. argue that the author does no adequately defend a premise in the argument. if one of the premises is false. argue that the author could have made a stronger arguement in defense in the thesis. the implication of the authors view. those are just a few examples. the criteria of this paper is the thesis is clearly stated, the remainder of the paper is a defense of the thesis, the position you are critiquing is clearly and accurately stated and the response is on point.